I am probably the least fickle person you will (n)ever meet. When I like someone or something, I’m usually in it for the long haul. I still wear T-shirts I got in middle school. My devotion to R.E.M. has not wavered since I was 10 or 11, even after “Around the Sun.” Hell, I still have (and listen to!) mixtapes people made for me when I was, like, 12! I still very much enjoy many things that society thinks people my age should have “grown out of,” and I’m still a fan of quite a few bands that Pitchfork-readin’ music snobs would have a hearty laugh at (if they ever smiled).
BUT, having said all that, there have been a few instances of me being really into a band only to change my mind soon after. I honestly think it’s a lot more fun to like stuff than it is to hate stuff, but once in a while everyone’s gotta talk some shit, you know?
Bright Eyes — When “Fevers and Mirrors” came out, I was dating a guy who was BALLS OUT for Conor Oberst. He made me one of the worst mixtapes I have ever received (and I don’t even mean just the bad songs/shitty bands on it, but the order was wack and the flow was nonexistent — he’d put, like, two or three songs by the same band in a row, which is just lazy and inexcusable), but the two songs I did like on it were “The Calendar Hung Itself” and “The Center of the World.” I bought “Fevers and Mirrors” and enjoyed it (still do, for the most part), and went to see Bright Eyes play at the 40 Watt in Athens, Georgia. It was a good show, if memory serves, but to be honest the details of the performance are a bit hazy because I MET MICHAEL STIPE that night and cried tears of joy the whole ride home. (Unfortunately not a joke.) I do remember Conor being quite intense, and he seemed to nearly be in tears for much of the show and just, you know, FEELIN’ IT, MAAAN. I was like, “Okay, I guess this dude is for real.” He seemed legit.
While I never bought any other Bright Eyes albums, I didn’t hate the guy or anything… until Desaparecidos came to town a year or two later. A group of us went to see Conor’s new band perform, and all the sudden the sad little floppy-haired acoustic-guitar-strummin’ boy was this trashy rocker dude who gulped Pabst Blue Ribbon on stage. Uh, what?! No thanks, faker. I still listen to “Fevers” on occasion, though, but I kind of think the guy behind the curtain is a douche.
Hot Hot Heat — I first heard of these guys from my best guy friend who has great taste in music (by the way, please do not think I am one of those girls who needs dudes to SCHOOL HER on music, because it ain’t even like that), and I went with him to see them live even though I knew nothing about the band. Well, it turned out to be a pleasant surprise, as I really enjoyed their show and bought their “Knock Knock Knock” EP. I listened to the EP pretty often, and when their album “Make Up the Breakdown” came out, I quickly snatched it up only to equally as quickly dislike it. It’s not often that a band sounds better live than on record, but these guys bucked that trend. All I could think while listening to the album was, “This guy is trying to sing badly on purpose!” It truly sounds that way! Their frontman has a decent voice, but I really feel like he tries to sound weird and out of tune on purpose for some reason! I find his screeching intolerable and haven’t listened to these guys since 2002, even though the bassist has Smiths lyrics tattooed on him.
Oasis — I’m an Anglophile. I’m enamored of Manchester, especially, so, you know, I had to like Oasis. Objectively, “Definitely Maybe” is a classic. “(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?” is fantastic. “Be Here Now” even has its moments, but after the (actually really awesome) B-side compilation, “The Masterplan,” I checked out. I saw Oasis live and even met and hung out with Noel Gallagher — who was shockingly nice and polite and is also hilarious — but I haven’t really been an active fan for 10 years or more. We had the TV on at work the other day and I actually asked, “Who is this?” when the latest Oasis video came on — that’s how unfamiliar I am with them these days. I’ll still rock those first two albums, though.
Counting Crows — HEAR ME OUT: These guys are basically one-album wonders to me. I will defend “August and Everything After” until my dying day; that album came out when I was 14 and it was (and is) so perfect. But in regard to any of their output after that, I’m on YOUR side: It sucks. So leave me alone.
Death Cab for Cutie — Oh man, I can hear the gnashing of indie kids’ teeth as I type this, but I have to BRING THE REAL to you guys right now: I used to LOVE Death Cab. LOVE THEM. My old roommate/current best friend introduced me to “Something About Airplanes,” and when we went to see them at the 40 Watt in Athens there were four other people there. Four. We ended up hanging out with the guys and during the next three tours for “Airplanes” and “We Have the Facts and We’re Voting Yes,” they slept on our floor and we all stayed up watching “Behind the Music” and eating Hot Pockets and laughing and talking, slumber-party style. Now, objectively, I will say that “Airplanes,” “We Have the Facts,” and “The Photo Album” are truly awesome albums. I still love them, especially “Airplanes.” However, around the time of “Transatlanticism,” when Death Cab became the favorite band of TV’s Seth Cohen, those dudes became too famous for us. All of a sudden they didn’t know who we were during their tour stop in our city, which was pretty convenient considering they could now afford hotel rooms. Hmph. Whatever to that. Is it a coincidence that their music got more boring as they grew bigger than their britches? Maybe. I’m not saying those dudes are raging assholes or anything (especially not the bassist — he was always cool with us), I’m just saying forgetting the little people is uncool. And seven-minute-plus songs get tedious.